Pohdintani rituaaleista jatkuu. Löysin Facebookista vanhan tuttuni eräältä keskustelufoorumilta Darrell Pursifulin. Hän on teologian tohtori, professori ja kustannustoimittaja ja on tutkinut varhaiskirkon rituaaleja. Hän suhtautuu niihin hyvinkin arvostavasti, siis kristillisiin rituaaleihin. Olen käynyt hänen kanssaan viimeisten blogitekstieni jälkeen kirjeenvaihtoa. Kopioin alle hänen luvallaan hänen minulle kirjoittamansa sähköpostin, jossa on mielestäni varsin viisasta asiaa. Jos teema kiinnostaa, lisää voi lukea hänen blogistaan alkaen 28.5.09 tekstistä, jossa hän neljässä osassa pohtii Heprealaiskirjeen kirjoittajan suhdetta rituaaleihin. Ovat antaneet minulle pohtimista päivittäin.
eli Darrell kirjoittaa:
I agree completely that even “good” rituals (dogmatically correct, emotionally satisfying, etc.) can have bad outcomes. That is one reason Jesus had so much to say about the Pharisees!
There are basically two forms of religious legalism we have to contend against in the realm of ritual:
(1) ritualism, which says the externals of the ritual have to be done just right for it to have a positive effect, and therefore obsesses over the tiniest details while missing the point of the whole (in English, we say, “missing the forest for the trees”), and
(2) formalism, which goes through the motions of the ritual with little or no thought for its significance.
I would simply suggest that we’re going to have rituals, no matter how hard we try not to! As you said, in your small group Bible study you found the need for a certain degree of orderliness or interpersonal agreement about how to pray. Something like that is to be expected when people try to organize their time together, no matter how close, loving, or equality-minded they are.
So, since we’re stuck with being ritualists (we are human, after all), let’s make sure we’ve come up with some good rituals! Let’s make sure our rituals encourage group participation, that our ritual leaders see themselves as facilitators of the worshiping community, not “professionals” who do something “for” us that we can’t do for ourselves, that our ritual spaces foster a sense of belonging and hospitality, etc. And let’s make sure we critique and challenge these rituals from time to time and teach people to avoid the dangers of ritualism and formalism.
I think I might post something from my dissertation on my blog later today that deals with these issues.

